Qualitative competitor analysis for social media and other channels

Datum: 14. July 2022

In the area of competition analysis we turn to part 3 of the qualitative competition analysis, after we have already presented in two articles the more well-known quantitative competition analysis. While in the latter above all the collection, sighting and evaluation of data about the general or special competition is at the center of the method, the qualitative competition analysis has a substantially different empirical material before it. And thus also a somewhat different task: Imagine that the competition takes on a certain ranking. Through the quantitative competition analysis the position in the ranking of a search engine can be explained relatively well by certain characteristics: The website of your competitors uses for example very specific keywords and has collected some very valuable backlinks. However, some offers on the website of your competition may not be used, whether because the offers or products are inferior, be it because potential customers are looking for the site and also find it good, but nevertheless because of the image that your competition communicates about themselves, they do not decide at all for the decisive step — a contact, a registration or a purchase.

Then it’s hard to decide on the basis of quantitative competition analysis, how you can build your online offer attractive and versatile in view of the competition. And exactly then the qualitative competition analysis comes into play, which we would like to bring you closer in the following article!

Quantitative or qualitative analysis of competition — what is the difference?

Both concepts, i.e. both the concept of quantitative and qualitative competition analysis, have been borrowed from social research. In the social sciences — for example sociology — the attributes mean quantitatively and qualitatively different empirical research methods. With regard to quantitative methods — similar to classical SEO competition analysis — especially the figures are in focus: Here, certain empirical objects are represented numerically on the basis of various observations, such as interviews, questionnaires or other surveys. From this statistics are produced, which then usually represent the course of a certain measured situation over a certain period of time as value. From this statistical survey can then possibly be drawn conclusions on a particular development or the statistics even allow to identify trends, trends and forecasts.

The qualitative methods usually use similar data collection. Here, too, interviews and questionnaires are used, and sometimes the methods also approach journalistic and reportage-like procedures. In order to understand the difference for competition analysis in concrete terms, it is enough to look at the difference between quality and quantity: In a quantitative analysis of your competitors, it is important to determine certain values, rankings and sizes that are limited and show a specific course that you can take as a benchmark for your own offer: your competition is high — and that’s why a comparison of the variety of your marketing methods with those of your competitors is worthwhile.

If you want to analyze your competition qualitatively, don’t necessarily count the different rankings: You don’t want to know how much the competition is, can and does. Then you want to know what the competition is like. For example, how do customers rate your competition? What convinces customers about your competition and what do you reject? How user-friendly, how practical and how easy is the offer of your competitors built up? How does the competition present itself, how does it present itself and how? All these are questions of a qualitative competition analysis!

Examples of qualitative competition analysis in online marketing

The offer of their competition can be as diverse as their appearances. First, you need to know where the competition is and how regularly it uses these performances. Is your competition represented at social media? If so, on what apps, through which channels and via which platforms? What do customers actually think of your competition? After all, it could also be your customers! And what is the image of the competition? How do they address the public — as a modern family business, influencers and video channels or perhaps in a very special way? The qualitative competition analysis is about finding out how your competition communicates and how your competition communicates. Finally, rankings and algorithms aren’t everything: a few stars at Google or Amazon are enough for potential customers to decide against a particular company. This may be your chance if you want to do better than your competitors.

Social media Competition analysis from a qualitative perspective

As already indicated, of course, social media is an extremely important field of application for qualitative social media competition analysis. Thus, almost all social media platforms also offer your corporate customers certain company profiles, which usually have quite extensive statistics and integrated analysis methods. However, these methods sometimes come to their limits. Because the figures do not always reveal something about whether your social media campaigns really had qualitative success, i.e. achieved goals such as the generation of user actions. Therefore, a qualitative view of the competition channels on the different social media platforms is excellently suited in order to provide information about the success of own methods.

The following applies: Studying is about copying — but imitation is allowed! In the qualitative social media competition analysis, it is not the goal to simply adopt successful strategies of competitors 1:1. You must always remain true to your own image and what you want to convey to your side of your offer. First, which companies are actually your competition based on similar offers. Then it has to be determined whether and which social media platforms will be used by your competitors in what way. Does your competitor XYZ have a Twitter account that hasn’t given a single tweet for two years? Then another competitor has to hold out for Twitter — if it makes sense for you to use Twitter!

What is really important for the success of a social media competition analysis!

The know-how about social media is also important in the social media competition analysis: The different platforms offer various functions and ultimately speak different languages. If short texts and liquid reacting to the audience are the focus of Twitter, for example, sharing links and image material looks very different than on Instagram or Facebook! Instagram also invites companies through its functions to tell a story to other users: there is a lot of potential for visual and audiovisual stories and hashtags and reaction play a major role.

For a successful qualitative social media competition analysis, a lot needs to be considered. For example, it can also happen that your competitors do not occur directly at all, but can be talked about by influencer accounts or profiles of your products.

And then there are the users: Not every user is a customer. And not necessarily potential customers. The different social media platforms have their own dynamics within the users — as already mentioned above: The different users of different platforms also speak different languages, so to speak.

Customer reviews, reviews & reviews as material of a competitor’s analysis

For the qualitative competitor analysis in the social media platforms for product reviews, it is actually not a big leap: after all, Facebook has long been integrating its own rating option for companies into his system. Once stars and opinions are awarded, the benefits of a qualitative analysis are once again shown: The average value of all evaluations of your competitors does not give you any information about how this average is composed and why it has the value that it has. Fortunately — besides Facebook also on Google, but also on countless, partly specific review portals — there is the connected comment function. And fortunately, customers comment in addition to their evaluation also gladly.

For the qualitative competitor analysis, the comment column has to be looked at in particular. Which ratings are relevant and which are simply spam or partly pure marketing? This is important to identify with a trained view, because here it is important to find out exactly what customers found good or bad at a company and its offer during a certain period of time. There is an enormous amount to find out for your company: Again, there is a chance to change or expand your own offer through the accurate analysis of your competitors, or quite clearly: improve. Learn from the mistakes of your competitors! If you find out, for example, by analyzing the customer reviews of a particular competitor, that he had increasing problems and delay in delivering his goods last month, you should definitely improve the quality of your own delivery and communicate considerably more strongly.

Conclusion — a qualitative competition analysis has a lot to do & much to gain

Finally, one thing is clear: qualitative marketing analysis is not easy because there is usually a wealth of sources and data about your competitors that would be very worthwhile for you to see. Likewise, many aspects of qualitative marketing analysis must always be related to the results of quantitative marketing analysis. Then, certain contradictions in the marketing of your competitors can be identified particularly well and then avoided for your own marketing. Furthermore, it is essential to provide know-how, knowledge and patience for qualitative marketing analysis. This is the only way to identify and interpret the really relevant data correctly.

Tags dieses Beitrags:


    Schreibe einen Kommentar zu "Qualitative competitor analysis for social media and other channels"

    Etwas HTML ist ok